How to Build an Engaged & Responsive Email List

by | May 28, 2019 | E-mail Marketing | 8 comments

This post might contain affiliate links meaning we get a small commission if you choose to purchase through those links (without any extra cost to you). Thanks for supporting us. Read full disclosure here >>

How to build an engaged and responsive email list

Every blogger/online marketer understands that the best way to generate sales is to have a large email list of subscribers. After they build that list, however, many bloggers begin to recognize that the list is large, but it doesn’t function to create sales or increase traffic.

Is that the case with you as well?…

That’s because it wasn’t built with the idea of creating a responsive email list and instead focused on quantity instead of quality.

The time to start building the right type of list is just as you get started, but even if you’ve already got a list, you can still tweak your business processes to get a better response after the fact.

Prefer watching videos over reading blog posts? I got your back. Watch the video from below.

Pay attention to how you create that email list

The biggest secret isn’t that you need a huge number of people on the list, but that you want a better conversion of subscribers to customers. You can do this by paying attention to how you are creating the list, how you are marketing it, and what is actually happening when you send out an offer. Here are some basic things you should know about a responsive mailing list.

  • Buying email lists doesn’t work – For the most part, you can buy thousands of emails on another person’s contact list and still generate very poor sales. The secret to creating a good list is to build one up naturally and organically so that people have a good relationship with you and your business.
  • Single opt-ins can be fooled – You may put out an opt-in list and be congratulating yourself on the number of sign-ups, that is until you find out many are fakes or generated by online bots. Learn how to use a double opt-in strategy to build a better list.
  • Targeted demographics are better than niches – Demographics tell you the reasons why people buy, while niches just assume everyone on your list is interested. You will have better luck by understanding the psychology of your list, rather than just relying on categorical niches, for email marketing.
  • Automate what you can – There are plenty of products and services to help streamline your online business. There’s no reason why you should be struggling with responding to each and every email unless there is some reason for personally responding. Learning about the technologies and tools available can save you valuable time and increase your bottom line.
  • People do have a price – It’s up to you to figure out what that price is. It may be that they are willing to subscribe if you give them a free short report. It might be that they will do it to enter a contest. It might be that they will reply to an email when they see savings in a product they like or when they get your personal attention. Pay attention and do what works for you.

For this, I have created a mini-report on 7 ways to grow your responsive email list. Get it now from below –

Organic is better

Organic, or naturally occurring lists, generally are quite a bit more responsive than lists created by buying email addresses from other bloggers/marketers.

The reason for this is that bought lists can contain a number of bad email addresses or contain people on them who are getting so much email from other marketers, that they ignore everything as spam.

One last reason, and the biggest reason, to use organic lists is that you can be liable for sending email to an address that hasn’t opted in to having their email published.

When you build your own organic lists, you know that the person has specifically requested to subscribe to your list and are genuinely interested in either you or your business.

Ways to create an organic email list

In this age of social networking, you will find that it isn’t as hard as it used to be to create an organic list. People are networking more and more online, and all you need to figure out is how to put the power of the Internet at your fingertips.

Don’t just put an opt-in form on your website and expect that using that simple action will generate a large organic list for you. People will still have to find your site, and if your traffic is low, this can be a major stumbling block.

The solution is to not just advertise your opt-in on your site but to do it elsewhere where traffic that is interested in your niche congregates. That’s where social networking comes into play.

Get in the habit of building an online presence on various social networking sites. You will have to post a profile and start networking with people on these sites to hook into potential customers.

Once you have them interested in either who you are or some common interests (related to what you market), you can start posting updates or links to things that you want to promote to get traffic from these sites back to your opt-in offers.

Demographics are Key

All successful bloggers/online business owners will tell you that when you go to set up a website or online business, you have to pick a hot niche. That is completely true, as, without a hot niche, you have less chance of generating enough traffic to make good sales.

However, when you go to market that niche via email lists, you will find that you will need to market to demographics more than to a niche.

In other words, you will want to focus on getting up close and personal with your prospective buyers, instead of just assuming that they want to buy your products because they signed up to your list.

Who are these people?

Demographics are typically segregated into a few marketing categories: gender, age, income bracket, ethnicity, and education level. Of course, you can set up any number of demographic variables to help you market to your niche, but these are pretty standard. Just knowing several of these demographics about who is visiting your site can substantially help you to increase the responsiveness of your email list.

How?… The trick is to send emails that talk personally to a specific group’s needs and provides that demographic with solutions to the problems that they see day-to-day.

For instance, say you are marketing laptops. You want a demographic of college-aged students or business professionals who require this piece of equipment.

You may also find that they need to be within a specific income bracket. You can put up surveys on your site and reward people for identifying who they are and what demographic they fall into. After that, you take that information and you set up different lists.

The one with college-aged students gets emails on how laptops can help them to complete assignments in between class or to take their studies with them anywhere. The email that goes to business people may target people who are in their cars (like real estate agents) or who spend a lot of time traveling for business. In that case, the biggest benefit is that it will increase their work productivity as they get the essentials of their business travel done.

Split or segment your email list into demographics

Once you start to figure out why people are buying, you can start to separate people into different mailing lists, according to their demographics.

You can set up one list for 18- to 25-year olds and another for those over 30. Next time you want to send out a promotion for a particular product or service, you will have a good idea of what psychological triggers work best with either list.

If your responsive email list is not growing then you’re doing something wrong. Learn how to grow your mailing list like the pros with my FREE List growth booster course.

track responsiveness

Once you start building email lists for marketing purposes, you will find that there are tools and services out there to help simplify the process. There’s no reason why you have to learn how to build a responsive mailing list from scratch when you can use the tools and services provided by others. Just make sure that they are simplifying your life and not complicating it.

Here are some tools or services that can help you do just that while encouraging your subscribers to be more responsive.

  • The Double Opt-In List – Instead of a single opt-in, you can choose to implement a double opt-in where the subscriber must confirm his/her email address via a response link that gets sent there. This is a great way to keep out spammers and fake email addresses from ruining the quality of your list.
  • Check Open + Click Rates – You should be able to check the open + click rates. This gives you a good idea of how many people are opening your emails and whether you are getting a good response to the subject headlines or click on your links.
  • Autoresponders + Automation – Set up automatic responders to certain types of actions people take, like registration or ordering. They can be for thank-yous, for back-end offers, and for confirmation of the action. The point is to make sure that customers feel they are being interacted with, even if you know it’s on automatic.

To get the types of tools above, many bloggers/marketers go to a service like ConvertKit that will provide email marketing support using these tools and more. They help people set up email campaigns using double opt-in lists and autoresponders and give you a good idea of who and how many are opening your emails + much more…

You can get a 30-day FREE ConvertKit trial here . (without using any credit card)

This is my special link, so you can take advantage of the tool for 30 days instead of regular 14.

Basic E-Mail tips

How you write your email is just as important as the tools and services you use to run your email marketing campaigns. You want to implement good practices to tempt people to respond to the email and avoid practices that turn people off.

Good practices to implement

  • Strong, Attention-Grabbing, Subject Headlines – Sometimes, this is all anyone bothers to read, simply because they can’t avoid it as they hit the delete key. You want a headline that pulls the reader in enough to get him/her to open the email when it lands in his/her inbox.
  • Use A Personal Name, If Possible – If you know the name of the person to whom you are sending the email from your list details, be sure to use that within the text. It adds a personal touch and makes the email more customized. There is an option in GetResponse you can use to pick up the first name in a database to add to the content of your emails so that it can be automated.
  • Keep It Short – There just isn’t enough time in the day to read long messages anymore. People will tend to skip large messages or skim them for the salient points. One way to get past the resistance to reading the email is just to keep it somewhat short.
  • Highlight Salient Points – Use white space, bolding, subheadings, noticeable fonts, and bulleted lists to get your message across. If a person can open your email and quickly determine what you want without too much fuss, you have a better chance of getting them to click your link offers.
  • Add Your Links/Offers – Make sure your link is easy to spot and available to click. Tell the reader what you are offering them if they click on the link. Make sure to sell benefits.
  • Unsubscribe Information – As a matter of courtesy, you should have unsubscribe information in every email you send. It’s not because you actually want people to unsubscribe, but because you don’t want to be accused of spamming them.

Avoid this

Do not spam people. This practice isn’t just annoying; it can get you in trouble with Federal regulators.

Know when to send

Responsive customers aren’t just a function of technology and slick marketing offers. They can also be a function of availability. Let’s face it; most people are NOT available during the holidays. That’s the time they are spending face-to-face time with their families and relatives and are generally not online.

If you create a stunning email marketing campaign and roll it out during a holiday, it is bound to flop. Therefore, knowing when to send and what times are best for what type of mailing action is crucial to getting better response rates.

Think work week

As a blogger/internet marketer, you may not follow a standard workweek, but more than likely, your customers do. That’s why it’s important to understand the psychology of why some days are better than others for different actions, and mostly it’s because people are following a standard workweek. Research has shown some clear trend on specific days for open rates.

Friday is fun day

Friday rolls around and people are ready to relax and take in the weekend. They may hop online to see what’s going on and what their friends are doing. That’s why Friday has the highest open rates of any other day of the week. If you want to have a better chance of people opening your emails, make sure you send them out before Friday.


It seems Tuesday is the day bloggers/Internet marketers send out most of their emails as it has the highest send rates. Realistically, Wednesday may be a better choice if you want to stand out from the crowd and get your emails in line for Friday. However, by Thursday, you will probably start to experience some drop-off in response rates.

When should you send it out?

Does this tell you when to send out your own email marketing campaigns?

Yes and no… It’s a good idea to try to use the standard workweek to make sure to avoid days when it definitely is not a good idea to send a campaign out, like Sunday.

Other than that, you can pay attention to the open rates for your particular subscribers to be sure they follow similar trends. It may be that their business doesn’t work on a standard workweek and that the general model won’t be well suited for you. So, do some testing of your own.

ConvertKit allows you to schedule broadcasts acccording to your subscribers’ time zones.

Keep in constant contact

Research has shown that people have to see an advertisement several times before they actually make the decision to buy. In an email marketing campaign, that means that perseverance pays off.

You may think that because you didn’t get a good number of bites the first time you sent out an offer that it’s not a good offer. It may simply need a bit more repetition to get the message across.

People tend to cozy up to things that they get more and more familiar with, so try to continue to market something a few more times before giving up on it. Also, try to keep in constant contact with the people on your mailing list.

If you let many days go by without a word, you really do lose the attention of the people on your list. In the worst case, they may already be wooed by your competitors. To keep this from happening, follow some easy rules.

Be frequent

You don’t want to deluge people with emails that are just sales promotions; however, you do want to be in constant contact with your mailing list. If you send out an email on Monday about some hot tips you discovered that can help make your subscriber’s life easier, they may be more willing to open the next one you send, which might be a product promotion.

Be frequent, but don’t overwhelm your readers with emails that are only to your own benefit. That’s a sure way for them to unsubscribe from your list.

Be consistent

If you say you will send out a newsletter every first Tuesday of the month, try to keep to that schedule. The more your subscribers understand the schedule, the more they will anticipate your next email and be looking forward to what you have to offer.

In a way, by being frequent and consistent and giving your customers things that appeal to them, you generate enthusiasm for being on your email list.

Be responsive too

Finally, the best way to generate a responsive email list is to also be responsive to your list’s needs. When problems arise, if you are there to provide solutions and generate goodwill, they will be there for you when you knock on their inbox to send them a marketing offer.

Try to respond to people personally when they first contact you so that they have some human relationship with you before you start to market to them.

Seek alternative methods

Email is not the only way to keep in contact with your mailing list. Offer them alternative ways to reach you and the other people participating on your site. This can be done through social networking sites, through online forums, and through informational seminars or courses offered online.

This can also be a great way to generate word-of-mouth for your business via referrals as friends tell other friends when some online event or interesting discussion is taking place online.

If you host these areas for discussion and networking on your own site, your list can grow astronomically bigger overnight with very little effort on your part.

Also read – 5 Important reasons why every blogger needs an email list

The nicest benefit of all is that it won’t just be a big list; it will also be a very responsive email list that participates in the discussions and networking that are happening on your website.

It is a captive audience to which you can market your products and services.

If you find this blog post useful, Make sure to pin it to your Pinterest profile. It’d take only a few seconds. 😉

How to build an engaged and responsive email list

Recommended resources:

Pinterest with Ell

Divi WordPress Theme

Do you know that our website was created without adding or messing with a single line of code? Yes! That’s the power you get with the Divi theme. We use Divi for all of our websites and our clients in our creative agency business and highly recommend it to everyone.
Legal Page templates for bloggers

Legal Page Templates

We use Lucrezia’s legal templates on our blogs and highly recommend it. She is an international lawyer (with a Ph.D., big stuff!) and has helped thousands of bloggers. She knows her thing and her legal page templates are the most affordable in the market.


Email Marketing Tool

ConvertKit was specifically created keeping bloggers and content creators in mind. It is the most recommended email marketing tool for bloggers.
Plus, if you choose to try it through our link, you get a special 30-day trial instead of the regular 14.

related posts:

One Thing To Do To Increase Click-Through Rates in Your Offer Emails

One Thing To Do To Increase Click-Through Rates in Your Offer Emails

Let me tell you a secret about email marketing! Regardless of the size of your list, your income will depend only on one factor: your ability to get your email list subscribers to click on your offers. Even if you have a list of a million people and you have an open...

9 Reasons Why Your Lead Magnet Is Not Converting (& How To Fix Them)

9 Reasons Why Your Lead Magnet Is Not Converting (& How To Fix Them)

Lead magnets are one of the best ways to grow your email list. If you're here to read this post, then obviously you know about that. But what you also know is that your lead magnets are not converting and you're here to find out the reasons. Many people would tell you...

How to Create an Irresistible Lead Magnet That Converts

How to Create an Irresistible Lead Magnet That Converts

Getting thousands of visitors to your website surely feels good, but all of that traffic is nearly useless unless it converts. If you're blogging to make money, then you already know the importance of building an email list for your blog/business. But, getting your...

Hey there! My name is Rahul Choudhary, the founder of Blog 2 Brand (formerly Your Blog Mentor!) and I am OBSESSED with helping online entrepreneurs and bloggers in making their passions profitable and popular!

I am a Martin Scorsese fan and a dog-lover. I enjoy solitude but I also like to work with like-minded people like you. Don’t forget to connect with me on social media (I share good stuff there too!).


  1. Pubali

    This is valuable information, and so relevant for all bloggers. Thanks for sharing.

    • Rahul Choudhary

      Thanks a bunch, Pubali.

  2. Kyra

    This post is very useful and I didn’t take into account the different days to send emails, but I will take that into account now.

    • Rahul Choudhary

      I’m glad, Kyra! Thanks for stopping by.

  3. Karen @ OnlineBlogAndBusinessHelp

    Great email list building tips, Rahul. I love the points you make about taking the workweek into consideration. I think a lot of people overlook that 🙂

    • Rahul Choudhary

      Exactly! It is a really important factor. Thanks for stopping by, Karen!

  4. Shikshit

    Nice piece of information here but I really need more basic information. I am just a beginner and really needed to have an email list subscription attached to the website. I would really appreciate if you may help me suggest which email tool to use and how to get it running on my website. As, I am not able to afford, would appreciate if you suggest some free service. I will definitely switch over to paid once I’ll have some money.

    • Rahul Choudhary

      I don’t really recommend any free email marketing tools and don’t have any tutorials for them as well.

      You can try Mailerlite as I have heard good things about it. But I personally didn’t like it much.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *